Secured Party Creditor and the "Strawman": What the Courts Said

Courts reject the idea that UCC filings make you a "secured party creditor" over your own name, or put you outside a court's power. A federal appeals court said these theories "should be rejected summarily, however they are presented."

The claim

Promoters say a birth certificate creates a separate legal person, the "strawman," whose name appears in all capital letters on government documents. Filing a UCC-1 financing statement against that name supposedly makes you its secured creditor. Supposedly that frees you from debts and court jurisdiction and lets you file liens against officials.

What the UCC actually does

Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code covers security interests that a debtor grants a lender in collateral, such as equipment or inventory, to secure a real loan. It requires a security agreement between two parties. A financing statement just gives public notice of that interest. You can't secure a debt you owe yourself. As a University of North Carolina School of Government guide puts it, the UCC is real and important commercial law, but it doesn't support these uses.

What courts decided

CaseCourt and yearWhat happened
United States v. Benabe, 654 F.3d 753U.S. Court of Appeals, 7th Circuit, 2011Claimed status as a "sovereign citizen," "secured-party creditor," or "flesh-and-blood human being" doesn't place anyone beyond a court's jurisdiction. Such theories "should be rejected summarily."
Taylor-Bey v. StateIndiana Court of Appeals, 2016A defendant who claimed to be a "Secured Party Creditor" and sovereign national argued the court lacked jurisdiction. Conviction affirmed, citing Benabe.
Monroe v. Beard, 536 F.3d 198U.S. Court of Appeals, 3rd Circuit, 2008Describes the "redemption" theory and the UCC filings that go with it (as cited in In re Hill).
In re HillBankruptcy court, E.D. Tennessee, 2015Explained that the redemptionist theory "propounds that a person has a split personality" and rejected it as having no basis in law.
Cook v. Kellogg Community Credit UnionFederal court, W.D. Michigan, 2024Borrowers claiming to be "non citizen Nationals" and a "legal estate" sued their credit union, court, and sheriff. The magistrate judge called these arguments meritless and recommended dismissal.

Liens against officials are a crime

Filing a false lien against a federal official is a federal crime (18 U.S.C. § 1521). Many states, including North Carolina, have their own versions, and courts can strike these filings quickly.

What actually works instead

  • For business lending: Use UCC Article 9 as intended, with a signed security agreement and a properly filed financing statement.
  • For protecting assets: Plan with a licensed attorney, and keep transfers clear of existing debts and claims.
  • For debts: Use your real rights, such as debt validation under 15 U.S.C. § 1692g, negotiation, or bankruptcy advice from an attorney.

← Back to the JAG Legal Library

Have a question about the UCC or your contracts?

Book a Consultation or call 831-316-6032.

General education, not legal or tax advice. JAG Consultants is not a law firm. For advice about your situation, consult a licensed attorney or CPA.